I’ve been meaning to do this post since then….but inner dilemma prevented me. I’m still on the fence about the course of action required, and after much deliberation, have decided to turn to you all for assistance.
Last week, I was at BigBazaar, doing some emergency shopping. I was late already and was fasting. Needless to say, I was in a rush to get back home. Once done with the shopping, I headed to the parking lot to get my bike. As I was keying in, a voice piped up behind me, “Joota polish kar dein?!”"
I nearly had a whip-lash injury as I jerked around to see who it was. The voice was familiar…and so was the opening line.
He was the same boy from last year!!
One fine day last year, I was shopping from Big Bazaar on my way home and came across this urchin. He demanded money and me, being in a hurry , brusquely asked him to get out of my way. Minutes after leaving Big Bazaar, I was racked with guilt and I vowed to make it up to him the next day.
I went back the next evening and looked around the parking lot. He was not there
Since then, every time I went to Big Bazaar, I’d keep an eye for this boy. But he never surfaced again, until last week. He even looked the same. There was hardly any change in his look or size. Malnutrition, maybe. I immediately dug into my purse to pull out the money I intended to give him. He took it mutely and stayed put. As I was stuffing my purse into the dicky, he said -
Boy : Hamein paise nahin chahiye. Aap hamein books do.
Me : What? Books? School jaate ho?
Boy : Nahin hum school nahin jaate. Joote polish karte hain.
Me : (perplexed) School kyun nahin jaate?
Boy : humko paise kamane hain.
Me : Phir padhayi kab karoge
Boy : (looking bewildered) Hum nahin padhte.
Me : To phir books kyun chahiye?
Boy : Books nahin didi….hamein Box chahiye. Joote polish karne ka box.
Me : (trying to figure out why the boy wants to earn) Kyun? Ghar par aur log nahin hai kya?
Boy : Hai na. Mummay hai. Dadi hai. Dadi hamesha beemar rehti hai. Usko bahot dawai lagta hai . Mummy kamati hai. Mujhe bhi paise chahiye. Aap box doge to mujhe aur paise milenge. Yahaan baki sab ladkoen ke paas box hai. Mere paas hi nahin hai…..
Me : (stunned into silence…trying to figure out what to say)
Boy : (looking at me keenly) Didi humko pata hai box kahan milega. Aap bas mujhe box khareed kar do.
Me : (mumbling more to myself than him) Sochenge.
And with uttering this so-called profound word, I pressed the starter and made my way. The boy kept yelling ‘didi’ behind my back. I didn’t look back.
And just like last year, I felt rotten all over again
It isn’t fair. To him or to me. It is not a big deal to shove money into his hands or even buy him that shoe box. I can convince myself that he will have a respectable job and income.
But is that what I would want for a 10-11 year old?? The moral dilemma eats at my brain. One part screams that I would be encouraging the boy into child-labour. The other part yells that he already is earning his wages, either by brushing shoes with that single shoe-brush or begging. A shoe-box would at least give him a decent income.
Much as I’m tempted to buy it for him, a part of me resists. This time, it is not about charity. This time, the issue is much bigger. I can simply give him the money and walk away. Let him buy the box or squander away the money. My job is done.
But the guilt of ruining a childhood, or being a party at it would constantly nag at me. I can never be at ease if I go ahead and give him what he wants.
The worst part?
After all this verbal exchange and moral monologues, I realized that I never bothered to ask him his name!
Trying to distance myself from him and his plight? Maybe.
But the fact remains, I wouldn’t feel at peace unless I do something. And I’m just not sure what I should be doing.
Any ideas, folks??










If there are other boys out there who already have a box, the guy will have more competition. I mean is there such a great demand to shoe-polish anymore?
Maybe you could go to his house, speak to his Mummy/ Dadi, verify the info he gave you and then suggest/help with alternate things the boy could do. Maybe attend night school or open school. It may be too late for his age to start off now but it is always good to know the letters. It will help him in the future.
I thought about visiting his house too. Frankly, I’m not too sure about the boy’s story. Have heard too many fibs from kids who beg!
But I think I can safely say that the kid hangs around the BB area. Will definitely catch him again some day
I wouldn’t suggest you to go alone anywhere with kids… because it can be very well a trap…Just be careful…
I just noticed a comment about an organization, hope he gets all the help… Let me know if I can help in any way from such a far place…
Yeah, I’m hoping too!
There is an NGO called Pratham that can help a child like this get an education. You will be able to find out who to contact on their website
http://www.pratham.org/
Thanks a lot for sharing this Jeanne.
Let me see where I can go from here
I’d missed the previous posts on this. Checking out his story seem like the first sane step. Maybe enrolling in a vocational course would work out for him while he does this shoe polish thing for the time being. The NGO could help there. It’s quite some task you’ve taken up. Best of luck.
Thanks OM. Need it badly
Oh! I would be in a dilemma as well…
I’m going to digress a bit (I don’t have any better suggestion to offer you)… isn’t it perfect that you met him again during Ramadan? Another opportunity to engage in charity? I hope you are able to help him in whatever way possible. I like that Pratham wala link.
Yes, it is the will of Allah that I help out that tyke. But I want to do something good and not just something wishy-washy.
I’m inclining towards Pratham too. Hope they are up to it
Yesterday when i read the email.. i just wanted to say get him the shoe box and end the dilemma.. coz anyway if u don’t give it, he might beg or do something else.. at least with the shoe box he will work… n maybe u cud probe him for night school…
but with the thoughts presented here.. my thinking feels so damn limited!
Presenting him to an organization seems more sensible.. hopefully things work out!
All the best!
Thanks Sheets
Reading after long time. How about “financing his family with expenses for “Medication Needs”, either through an NGO or through group of friends and convince him/his family for his study.
Yes, that thought did occur to me. I have to trace his family though. That is, once I catch hold of that guy again.
He seems to have disappeared again